The Pass · article

What makes a great cafe Pho

Pho is the national soup of Vietnam. A clear, fragrant broth simmered for four to six hours. Paper thin slices of raw beef, cooked only by the heat of the broth as it hits the bowl. Flat rice noodles, and a side plate of fresh herbs, chilli and lime. Cafes that have started serving it are giving their lunch menu something different, and doing it well is simpler than it looks.

Try the free demo Free and view only, no credit card required.
From The Pass · 6 min read
What makes a great cafe Pho
The opening

A great soup, properly understood

Pho is the national soup of Vietnam. The broth is clear and fragrant, with a deep beef flavour. The noodles are soft and flat. The beef is sliced so thin you can see the spoon through it. The side plate of bean sprouts, mint, Thai basil, coriander, sliced chilli and a wedge of lime is part of the dish, not a garnish. Customers finish the bowl themselves at the table, one squeeze and one handful at a time.

Few cafes serve it, because Pho looks like a specialist dish with a long ingredient list and hours of broth. The technique is plain and much of the prep is hands off, and once the broth is in the cold room the bowl gets to the pass faster than a Bacon and Egg Roll.

The kitchen craft

The broth is the dish

Everything good about Pho is in the broth. Get it right and the rest is assembly. Get it wrong and no amount of herbs or lime will save the bowl. So put your effort into the broth.

Here is the cafe method. Toast a small handful of whole spices (cinnamon stick, star anise, cloves, fennel seeds, coriander seeds, black peppercorns) in a dry stockpot for a minute or two until fragrant. Add water and beef stock powder, about eight litres for a ten portion batch, and a few thick slices of fresh ginger. Bring it to a gentle simmer, turn the heat down low and leave it alone for four to six hours.

The one rule the dish depends on is that the broth never boils. Boiled broth goes cloudy and bitter. Simmered broth stays clear and sweet. The window is narrow, 85 to 95 degrees, and a probe thermometer is the cheapest insurance you can buy for it. The eight litres reduce over the simmer, leaving roughly 4.6 to 5 litres of finished broth, or 450ml a serve. Strain it through a fine sieve, throw out the spices and ginger, cool it fast and keep it cold for service.

That's the whole technique. The beef is sliced paper thin and tossed with fish sauce, five spice and garlic. The garnish prep is picking herbs, slicing chilli, cutting lime wedges and washing sprouts. None of it takes more than half an hour. The only long step is the four hour simmer, and you don't need to stand over it.

The four marks

What lifts a Pho from good to great

Once the broth is right, the bowl comes down to four small things. Each is easy to get wrong and just as easy to get right.

The clarity of the broth. A great Pho broth is the colour of weak tea and clear enough to read newsprint through. Cloudy broth is the most common fault, and it's nearly always because the pot crept up to a boil. Keep it below a boil the whole time and the broth comes out clean.

The thinness of the beef. Slice the sirloin against the grain, as thin as you can. Thirty minutes in the freezer firms it up enough for a sharp knife to slide through cleanly. The slices should be translucent. When the boiling broth hits them in the bowl they cook to rare in seconds and stay tender. Thick slices go grey and tough.

The herb plate. Bean sprouts, mint, Thai basil, coriander, a few rings of red chilli and a wedge of lime on a small plate beside the bowl. That plate is for the customer to use: they tear the herbs into the broth, add sprouts by the handful, squeeze the lime and decide how much chilli they want. Serve the bowl without it and you've taken away half the dish.

The temperature of the pour. The broth has to be at a full rolling boil when it goes over the beef. If the bulk pot has dropped below that, bring a portion back to the boil in a small saucepan to order. The boiling broth cooking the raw beef is the whole point, and a lukewarm pour leaves the beef grey and the soup cold.

Where it sits on the menu

What the bowl earns

In the HospoSure Test Kitchen a Classic Beef Pho costs about $5.90 a serve in food, mostly in the beef and the rice noodles. It sells for $24 ($21.82 before GST), which puts food cost around 27%, a little under the 28 to 35% target and good for a substantial lunch, and the bowl is strong enough to be the centrepiece of the menu, not a side option.

What it does for the room is harder to measure. A cafe that serves a proper Pho gets known for it. It photographs beautifully, with the herb plate alongside and steam coming off the broth. Regulars come back for it every Tuesday lunch for a whole winter. It also suits a wide range of tastes and diets without much change, which helps when your menu has to please a wide room.

The verdict

The bowl worth the simmer

Pho is a generous dish. The broth has been on since morning, the beef was sliced by hand for the bowl, and the herb plate lets customers finish lunch their own way. None of it is hard on its own. You just have to give the broth its time and keep it below a boil for the four hours it needs.

Make the broth on a quiet morning. Slice the beef on a board with a sharp knife. Pick the herbs. Pour the boiling broth with a clean ladle.

Common questions

Common questions about cafe Pho

What is Pho?

A traditional Vietnamese soup of clear, spiced beef broth poured hot over flat rice noodles and paper thin raw beef. The broth starts with beef stock, ginger and a small spice mix of star anise, cinnamon, cloves, fennel and coriander seeds, then simmers very gently for several hours. At the table it's finished with bean sprouts, fresh herbs, sliced chilli and lime.

Why is the broth poured at a rolling boil?

Because the beef goes into the bowl raw. The boiling broth cooks it in seconds, to rare, as it hits the slices. If the broth is below a boil when you pour, the beef stays grey and underdone. The boil isn't optional.

What cut of beef is used in Pho?

Sirloin is the usual cafe choice. It has good flavour at a moderate price, slices cleanly into paper thin pieces and cooks evenly in the broth. Buy it from a supplier whose beef is suitable for eating rare, and use it fresh on the day. Thirty minutes in the freezer before slicing makes paper thin cuts much easier.

Can Pho be made gluten free?

Yes, if you check two ingredients. Beef stock powder and fish sauce vary by brand, and some contain wheat. Check both are gluten free on each delivery and the bowl is naturally gluten free, because rice noodles, fresh herbs and the broth itself contain none.

How long does the broth take?

At least two hours, ideally four to six. Keep the simmer very gentle and never let it boil, so the broth stays clear. You can mostly leave it alone, so a kitchen can make the broth on a quiet afternoon and run the bowl all week. Strained broth holds three days refrigerated and freezes well, so chill what you'll use in the next three days and freeze the rest for later in the week.

How fast does a Pho hit the pass to order?

About three minutes once the broth is hot and the beef is portioned. The rice noodles take two minutes, the beef is already sliced and waiting, and the broth is already at a rolling boil on the stove. Ladle, plate the herbs, send it. That's faster than most cafe lunch dishes.

From the kitchen

The cafe Pho recipe behind this article

The Slow Simmered Beef Pho in this article is one of 250+ chef tested dishes in the HospoSure dish library. It comes with the broth method, batch yields and the herb plate, all costed for Australian suppliers.

Try the free demo